Talking Dog Fishing Customer Reviews

Name: Talking Dog Fishing
Brand: Talking Dog Fishing
Rating: 5 (9 reviews)

100% would recommend

5/5

From 9
verified reviews

Jack AI Customer Experience Snapshot

Captain Todd Malicoat delivers exceptional flats fishing experiences with impressive results that keep customers coming back. Anglers consistently catch tarpon, snook, snapper, grouper, and even hammerhead sharks under his expert guidance. Todd teaches valuable techniques like proper loop knot tying to maximize lure action, and his extensive knowledge of local reefs and tides ensures productive outings every time. Customers appreciate Todd's generous approach to sharing fishing knowledge rather than hoarding trade secrets. His worldwide fishing experience from Miami sailfish tournaments to Louisiana yellowfin tuna runs brings professional expertise to every charter. Families and experienced anglers alike enjoy memorable days with this knowledgeable captain who creates lifetime fishing memories in Key West waters.

AI-generated from the text of customer reviews

Tarpon

Flats Fishing

Loop Knot

Professional Captain

Trophy Fish

Local Knowledge

Sailfish

Memorable Experiences

Photos from Real Customers

See all images

Book Your Next Trip With Us

All Reviews

Ian Scrivener

June 23, 2026

Trip - 3 Hr Shark Trip - $499 on June 23, 2026

Greta trip with Captain Todd. We were on sharks within minutes. Hooked over seven in out three hours aw well as catching a few snappers and almost a giant barracuda. Had so much fun, we are going out for a second trip.

Was this helpful ?

Sean Fagan

May 19, 2026

Trip - Quick Fishing Trip In Key West | 2 Hour Intro To Fishing Charter on May 19, 2026

Had a great morning out with Captain Todd. We caught several fish including a shark and a Goliath Grouper! Was even able to get a couple of shots with fly rod at some tarpon back in the mangroves. Just a phenomenal morning and I definitely recommend Captain Todd and Talking Dog Charters.

Was this helpful ?

Robert Biddle

February 6, 2026

Trip - Baitfish Boat Ride Trip In Key West | 2 Hour Intro To Fishing Charter on February 6, 2026

Under the extreme weather conditions, Captain Todd went out of his way to put me on fish. He was very knowledgeable and taught me stuff about the Keys and the fish in the area. I'll be coming back during different seasons and booking with him.

Guide responseWas this helpful ?

Captain ToddReplied on February 9, 2026

Thanks Robert - it was a pleasure fishing with you, and hope we get to do it again. Safe travels, and let me know when you make it back down.

Greg Shaughnessy

November 18, 2025

Trip - on November 18, 2025

I had a great time fishing with Capt. Todd, catching three bonefish. He even got in the water to snap some pics, which I really appreciated. He is very knowledgeable and easy going. I'm planning on booking another trip with him soon.

Was this helpful ?

Enrique Zamora

November 5, 2025

Trip - on November 5, 2025

Todd is the man and great fisherman!

Was this helpful ?

George (Mr. George)

October 31, 2025

Trip - on October 31, 2025

I had the pleasure of going out with Captain Todd last Tuesday, and it turned out to be an incredible experience. I was down in the Keys with an open day and decided to look for a fishing trip after chatting with a few people at Mac’s. I called some charters who were booked, but one of them recommended Captain Todd, and he was able to fit me in that same afternoon! We met at the Beach Weekend dock and headed out for a few hours. The trip was fantastic. I had never caught a shark before, so actually hooking one was an unforgettable moment. We also caught a couple of tarpon, and Captain Todd even took some photos and videos of the catches. It was an exciting, memorable trip and truly a once in a lifetime catch for me. I highly recommend fishing with Captain Todd if you get the chance.

Was this helpful ?

Brent Csutoras

October 29, 2025

Trip - on October 29, 2025

I've fished with Captain Todd multiple times over the years, and every single trip has been awesome. If you're looking for a guide who knows how to find fish, Todd's your guy. The thing about Todd is he just has this ability to find fish. You know, he'll pull up to what looks like a random spot, point, and boom, within minutes we're catching fish after fish. I mean, it's like he has GPS for where they're holding. His experience really shows time and time again. Todd handles everything, gear, tackle, bait, licenses, so you just fish. He's super knowledgeable but also willing to share what he knows instead of keeping it all to himself. The atmosphere is just chill, he's a genuinely nice guy who makes the day fun whether the fish are biting nonstop or you're working for them. Over multiple trips we've consistently caught tarpon, snook, snapper, and sharks. The action is usually steady and Todd works hard to keep you on the bite. I recommend Todd to everyone I talk to about fishing in Key West, and I'm already looking at dates to book again. Whether you're just starting out or you've been fishing forever, you'll have a great time and catch fish with Talking Dog Fishing.

Was this helpful ?

Spencer Blanton

October 21, 2025

Trip - on October 21, 2025

Top notch flats fishing guide with great knowledge and no how. Taught me how to tie a "loop knot" which is important to get the most action out of your flies, jigs, and lures. Very fun to fish with as well! Highly recommended! Caught 6 tarpon, and jumped at least 20 in 2 hour span on a late afternoon/evening trip, as well as a nice keeper snapper. You will not be disappointed 💪

Was this helpful ?

Maritza Rosa

September 28, 2025

Trip - on September 28, 2025

I’ve had some of my best fishing experiences with Captain Todd! Caught tons of fish, including my very first hammerhead and tarpon. Highly recommend for an exciting and memorable day on the water!

Was this helpful ?

Fish Key West with the Best

Key West Charter Reviews & Customer Testimonials

See what guests are saying about their unforgettable experiences with Talking Dog Fishing in Key West. These verified reviews come from anglers of all ages who’ve enjoyed private inshore fishing trips for tarpon, sharks, snapper, and more. Many guests highlight the fun, laid-back atmosphere Captain Todd creates, along with his deep knowledge of the local waters. Whether it’s a child landing their first fish or a seasoned angler chasing a trophy tarpon, reviews consistently mention how memorable, exciting, and well-guided each trip was.

Captain Todd Malicoat’s experience and personalized approach shine through in every testimonial.

We had an absolutely incredible day on the water with this Captain Todd! From start to finish, everything was top-notch. The captain was professional, knowledgeable, and clearly passionate about what he does. He knew exactly where to go and how to put us on the fish.

Within minutes of casting, we were hooking into beautiful sea trout, followed by some exciting snook action that kept us on our toes. We saw jumps, long runs, and a real test of gear and technique. The captain coached us through...

Blake C., Miami, FL

Fishing with Captain Todd Malicoat of Talking Dog Fishing was an amazing experience. From the moment we stepped on the boat, it was clear we were in the hands of a true professional, Captain Todd’s knowledge of the waters around Key West is unmatched—I had never caught a trout so that was our target then snook; he knew exactly where to go, what bait to use and it was non-stop action from there. He was able to adjust for changing conditions throughout the day.

Jessica Z., Miami Gardens, FL